| Paguristes grayi Benedict, 1901 |
| Paguristes haigae Ayón-Parente & Hendrickx, 2007 |
| Paguristes hernancortezi McLaughlin & Provenzano, 1974 |
| Paguristes holmesi Glassell, 1937 |
| Paguristes hummi Wass, 1955 |
| Paguristes inconstans McLaughlin & Provenzano, 1975 |
| Paguristes limonensis McLaughlin & Provenzano, 1975 |
| Paguristes oculiviolaceus Glassell, 1937 |
| Paguristes oxyophthalmus Holthuis, 1959 |
| Paguristes perrieri Bouvier, 1895 |
| Paguristes praedator Glassell, 1937 |
| Paguristes puncticeps Benedict, 1901 |
| Paguristes rectifrons Benedict, 1901 |
| Paguristes sanguinimanus Glassell, 1938 |
| Paguristes sericeus A. Milne-Edwards, 1880 |
| Paguristes spinipes A. Milne-Edwards, 1880 |
| Paguristes tenuirostris Benedict, 1901 |
| Paguristes tortugae Schmitt, 1933 |
| Paguristes ulreyi Schmitt, 1921 |
| Paguristes visor Henderson, 1888 |