| Mutilla concolor Cresson, 1865 |
| Mutilla connectens Cresson, 1865 |
| Mutilla contumax Cresson, 1865 |
| Mutilla copano Blake, 1871 |
| Mutilla cressoni Blake, 1870 |
| Mutilla croesus Gerstaecker, 1874 |
| Mutilla cruciata Smith, 1855 |
| Mutilla culta Cameron, 1894 |
| Mutilla cyllene Cameron, 1894 |
| Mutilla cypris Blake, 1871 |
| Mutilla cyra Cameron, 1894 |
| Mutilla daedala Cameron, 1894 |
| Mutilla derelicta Smith, 1879 |
| Mutilla ducalis Smith, 1879 |
| Mutilla eggeri Dalla Torre, 1897 |
| Mutilla erebus Melander, 1903 |
| Mutilla erudita Cresson, 1875 |
| Mutilla erythrina Say, 1836 |
| Mutilla eximia Blake, 1886 |
| Mutilla falsa Dalla Torre, 1897 |