| Pagurus bullisi Wass, 1963 |
| Pagurus carolinensis McLaughlin, 1975 |
| Pagurus clypeatus Fabricius, 1787 |
| Pagurus cokeri Hay, 1917 |
| Pagurus criniticornis (Dana, 1852) |
| Pagurus cubensis de Saussure, 1858 |
| Pagurus findleyi Ayón-Parente & Hendrickx, 2012 |
| Pagurus gladius (Benedict, 1892) |
| Pagurus insignis de Saussure, 1858 |
| Pagurus lepidus (Bouvier, 1898) |
| Pagurus longicarpus Say, 1817 |
| Pagurus maclaughlinae García-Gómez, 1982 |
| Pagurus marshi Benedict, 1901 |
| Pagurus merimaculosus Glassell, 1937 |
| Pagurus miamensis Provenzano, 1959 |
| Pagurus nanodes Haig & Harvey, 1991 |
| Pagurus parvus (Benedict, 1892) |
| Pagurus politus (Smith, 1882) |
| Pagurus pollicaris Say, 1817 |
| Pagurus provenzanoi Forest & de Saint Laurent, 1967 |